St. Peter`s Catch Restaurant in Montauk

The lobster meal may look expensive but is worth every penny!!! The extra portion of clams coming with it was a delightful surprise

#delish #fresh great fish tacos, best lobster roll we had all week! And conveniently next to montauk brewing co

Fish tacos were so delicious and so fresh. Best fish tacos ive ever had.

Very good lobster roll. Friendly staff. Pricey but it’s Montauk and u do get what u pay for. 4/5 due to smaller portion than I expected. And fries— pass on those.

Great local restaurant that doesn't charge insane prices.

Other years their fish plater was fresh flounder, now it is simply a fish plater. Plus it was salty

Great fresh seafood. Fish and shrimp tacos were excellent!

The Marlin spread on Ritz crackers is to die for! Also fish and chips (French friesWith skins) is excellent and good price$13! New England clam chowder is a 10!

We went out to Montauk for my brother's bachelor party, and bought lobsters and clams for the whole party. When we got back to the house, we realized they didn't have any of the pots we needed and all the stores were closed. The team here was incredible and let us borrow their pot for the night. Everything was fantastic, and they saved the night!

Lobster roll is on smaller side for the price

LOVE THIS PLACE!!! The food is amazing and fresh. They are also so nice here :)

The best seafood on Long Island. The calamari is world class. Bring cash

Amazing food hood price.

I don't like seafood but we come to Montauk for a week every year and I eat their fish tacos at least 3 times while I am there.

$10 for a great fish and chips lunch, can't beat it. Cash only, you've been warned.

Best fish taco's around. Everything cooked fresh, Amazing scallop's...

Worst service ever. Waited for 20 min only to find out they lost our number. If you don't want to sit around waiting, go somewhere else for greasy food.

Went there during a long weekend stay in Montauk. First time around it was great, the second not so much. Knocking off two stars for lack of consistency and some confusion with serving the food.

It used to be the best kept secret... a fish market that made the best fish taco in the universe. now they're a restaurant catering to the montauk partiers. the fish taco isn't as perfect... but it's still the best.

Love their fish toco. Have to go eat there every time out in mtk. Owner is a really nice gent friendly and happy and staff lovely ladies. So you must try then go next door to Montauk brewery.

It's probably the best experience you can get in the area. The restaurant/ fish market is local which means you can buy a fish that went straight out of the water the day you are eating it. It has a great ambience and looks very cute.

Tucked away from the beach next to the Montauk Brewing Company, is St. Peter's Catch. This well curated fish market and fry bar has well seasoned and well prepared take out meals. They have picnic tables with umbrellas in their 'front yard.'

The fish taco's are amazing!

Best butterfly Shrimp in town

Pretty good. But much better lobster rolls in town for the same money.

Unbelievable fish tacos and great prices for local catch fish.

Food was ok but way overpriced for the portions

Great little place to eat. Disappointed I could only for one meal in!

Excellent quality fish and great customer service. A little pricey, but not unexpected in Montauk.

Great fish tacos and calamari! Yum

Amazing lobster Rolls! Unspoiled by dressings or spices, just meat on a fresh New England style bun. I am a bit spoiled since there are lobster fisherman in my family from Maine. I have never had lobster this fresh unless it came off my cousins boat that day.

Smoked marlin dip is amazing. He will give you a sample if you ask. Trust me you wont be sorry.

So disappointed in their lobster roll. It was the worst lobster roll ever! It was literally just one lobster claw on a bed of lettuce. No dressing no nothing. Don't waste your money. I could have gotten a whole lobster for just a few dollars more somewhere else. Overrated